| 2020 | |
| Mecolett Bradley | Delta State University |
| Dionne Templet | University of Mobile |
| Kelsey Hodges | University of West Florida |
| Kennedy Carruth | Belhaven University |
| Alayna Adams | Belhaven University |
| Danielle Williams | Mississippi College |
| 2019 | |
| Maddie Seymour | University of Mobile |
| Lindsie Sanders | University of Mobile |
| 2018 | |
| Crislyn Graham | Miles College |
| Nate Montgomery | Auburn University-Manager |
| Cassidy Huff | William Carey University |
| 2017 | |
| Kerri Irvin | Belhaven University |
| Brianna Dollar | Belhaven University |
| Katie Lee | Huntingdon College |
| Alyssa Singleterry | Huntingdon College, ASBA (Pro League) |
| Whitney Jemison | Belhaven University |
| Timothy Shaw | Troy University-Manager |
| 2016 | |
| William Hess | Southeastern Louisiana University-Manager |
| Ashton Gautreaux | Our Lady of the Lake University |
| Makayla Reed | Belhaven University, ASBA (Pro league) |
| Cassidy Comstock | Belhaven University |
| Kaylyn Lary | Martin Methodist University |
| Kaitlyn Blubaugh | Belhaven University |
| 2015 | |
| Haley Nichols | William Carey University |
| Randi Bass | Union College (KY) |
| Kylie Bradley | Centenary College |
| 2014 | |
| Shelby Jo Vinson | Lindsey Wilson College |
| Merina Young | Jackson State University |
| Annabelle Smith | Blue Mountain College |
| Sara Beth Williamson | University of Alabama at Birmingham |
| Avery Godwin | University of North Alabama |
| 2013 | |
| Spencer Adkinson | Southeastern Louisiana University |
| Taylor Felts | Martin Methodist University |
| Heather McGuirk | Huntingdon College |
| 2012 | |
| Heather Johnston | Troy University |
| Hali Sclafini | Mississippi State University |
| 2010 | |
| Heather Smith | Faulkner University |
| Cassie Gable | Faulkner University |
| Brooke Bryan | Shorter University |
| Jessica Stapleton | WVU Tech |
| 2009 | |
| Teri Johnson | Mississippi College |
| Stephanie Beahn | University of West Alabama |
| Meagan Sloke | University of West Alabama |
| 2007 | |
| Mallory Meadows | Belhaven University |